Living near the Jersey Shore means access to some of the freshest seafood on the East Coast. From the lobster boats of New England to the local catches off our own coast, Monmouth County's best restaurants celebrate the ocean's bounty with dishes that highlight quality ingredients and expert preparation.
The Jersey Shore Seafood Tradition
New Jersey's coastline has shaped the culinary identity of Monmouth County for generations. Italian-American families brought the tradition of the Feast of the Seven Fishes on Christmas Eve. Portuguese fishermen contributed their love of grilled preparations. And the classic shore clam bar established seafood as casual, accessible, and fresh.
Today, the best seafood restaurants in Monmouth County honor these traditions while elevating the experience. The key is always the same: start with exceptional ingredients and let the quality shine.
Understanding Fresh Seafood
What makes seafood "fresh"? It's more than a marketing term—it's about sourcing, handling, and timing. Here's what to look for:
Signs of Quality Seafood
- Fish: Clear eyes, firm flesh, ocean-fresh smell (never "fishy")
- Shellfish: Shells should be intact and closed; live lobsters should be active
- Preparation: Cooked seafood should be moist, not dry or rubbery
- Sourcing: Good restaurants know where their seafood comes from
Must-Try Seafood Dishes
When dining at a quality seafood restaurant in Monmouth County, certain dishes showcase what the kitchen can do:
Lobster
The king of East Coast seafood. At The Squire, our Twin Lobster Tails feature cold water lobster—sweeter and more tender than warm water varieties. During summer, our Jersey Shore Lobster Nights (Thursday through Sunday) offer fresh Maine lobster at exceptional value.
Halibut
Often overlooked, halibut is one of the most versatile and delicious fish available. Our Parmesan Crusted Halibut—topped with a crisp Parmesan crust and finished with citrus beurre blanc—is consistently one of our most celebrated dishes. The fish is flaky yet substantial, elegant yet satisfying.
Shrimp
From classic shrimp cocktail to stuffed shrimp with seafood filling, jumbo shrimp anchor many great seafood menus. Look for preparations that enhance rather than mask the shrimp's natural sweetness.
Scallops
Diver scallops—hand-harvested by divers rather than dredged—represent the peak of scallop quality. When properly seared, they develop a caramelized crust while staying tender inside. They're featured prominently on our Surf & Turf Board.
Surf & Turf: The Best of Both Worlds
Monmouth County's unique position—close to both ocean and farmland—makes it natural territory for surf and turf. The classic combination pairs a quality steak with lobster tail, but the concept extends further.
At The Squire, our signature Surf & Turf Board takes this tradition to its logical conclusion: a 32oz Porterhouse paired with cold water lobster tails, jumbo shrimp, and diver scallops. It's designed for sharing and represents the best of both land and sea.
Perfect Pairings
Seafood and wine are natural partners. Here's what to order:
- Lobster: Chardonnay—the butter and richness complement each other
- Halibut: Pinot Grigio or a light Chardonnay
- Salmon: Pinot Noir works beautifully with salmon's richness
- Shrimp: Sauvignon Blanc or a dry Rosé
Seasonal Considerations
Like all ingredients, seafood has seasons. While modern sourcing makes most fish available year-round, there are times when certain items peak:
- Summer: Lobster season peaks; soft-shell crabs available
- Fall: Local fluke and striped bass at their best
- Winter: Oysters are prime; traditional Feast of Seven Fishes
- Spring: Scallop season; lighter preparations emerge
Beyond the Boardwalk
While the classic Jersey Shore seafood shack has its place, Monmouth County also offers elevated seafood experiences. Look for restaurants that:
- Source thoughtfully and can tell you where their fish comes from
- Prepare seafood with technique, not just tradition
- Offer a wine program that complements the menu
- Balance innovation with respect for the ingredients
Experience Jersey Shore Seafood at The Squire
Located minutes from the shore in West Long Branch, The Squire embraces the Jersey Shore's seafood tradition while elevating it to fine dining standards. Our seafood menu features both classic preparations and chef-driven creations, all built on exceptional ingredients.
Whether you're craving lobster, exploring our halibut, or going all-in on the Surf & Turf Board, we invite you to experience what Jersey Shore seafood can be.
Craving Fresh Seafood?
Reserve your table and experience the best of Jersey Shore seafood.
Make a Reservation
